Skip to main content

Challenging Desperate Slurs and Systemic Racism


Many of us must have heard about a recent Desperate Housewives episode where the character played by Teri Hatcher denigrated Philippine medical doctors by asking, “Can I see his diploma, just to make sure it did not come from some med school in the Philippines?” or words to that effect.  This caused a major uproar among Filipinos, including those living abroad, which then led to the issuance of an apology by the producers of this very popular television show.

The knee-jerk reaction from the Filipino community is quite understandable, considering the fact that numerous Philippine medical school graduates have excelled and continue to excel in their fields in various parts of the world, including the United States.  Therefore, this act of belittling the quality of medical education in the Philippines is extremely offensive and undeserved.   Beyond the knee-jerk reaction however, this incident should also remind us that racial stereotyping is a deeply embedded and systemic problem, which cannot simply be remedied or eradicated by an empty apology.  

This incident also highlights the need for continuing and comprehensive efforts to break down stereotypes through education, advocacy, lobbying and more education.  Ignorance, after all, breeds insensitivity, insensitivity breeds hatred, and hatred breeds all these nonsensical attitudes.

Canada is no stranger to similar types of attitudes.   While proud of its multiculturalism, the Canadian society is still prone to stereotyping which targets new immigrants and members of non-white ethnic groups in particular.  Sociological and statistical studies abound which prove that racial profiling, stereotyping, and outright discrimination are still some of the major obstacles faced by these groups of people in obtaining full equality within Canadian society.

The lack of proportionate political representation for instance, is very evident in the highest echelons of government.  While non-whites now comprise a greater majority of the Canadian population, a visible majority of government officials, judges and parliamentarians remain predominantly white.   Non-whites are also very much underrepresented in the medical and legal profession or in the corporate arena.  Consequently, the socio-economic make-up of society reflects a disproportionate representation of people of color toiling in low-paying jobs such as domestic work (e.g. Citizenship and Immigration Canada statistics show that some 80% of those who enter Canada via the Live-in Caregiver program are from the Philippines).

The call for full accreditation of foreign credentials is another area, which cries out for immediate attention and full-blown advocacy.  While the Canadian government has recently launched some efforts to this end, there is still much to be done towards allowing countless foreign trained professionals obtain meaningful jobs within their areas of expertise.   Again, ignorance of, and suspicion over the quality of foreign-earned credentials are among the factors, which leave many highly qualified professionals unable to practice in Canada.  The lack of so-called “Canadian experience” leads them to a frustrating cycle of unemployment, financial burden, and eventual deskilling.   It is recognized that the respective organizations which conduct the evaluation of foreign credentials and the regulation of professions are mainly private entities.  However, the government still plays a significant role in ensuring that principles of equality, fairness and non-discrimination are upheld even by private entities.   Moreso, when public interest issues such as these are at stake.

But all is not hopeless.  With sincere and concerted efforts, we can still achieve full equality.   To start, we can try to shed the remnants of colonial mentality that we, as Filipinos, inherited through centuries of colonial history as a nation.  We can also unite and join efforts with other marginalized groups in advocating and lobbying for systemic, genuine and long-lasting reforms.  

***

Calling all lawyers and law students (Canadian and/or foreign-trained): 

Speaking of joint and concerted efforts, a group of Asian lawyers and jurists have recently formed the Federation of Asian Canadian Lawyers (FACL).   Its mission statement includes the promotion of  equity, justice, and opportunity for Asian-Canadian legal professionals and the
community” as well as “advocacy, community involvement, legal scholarship and professional development.”   The launching conference of FACL will be held on Saturday, November 3, 2007 at the University of Toronto law school from 1-5:30 pm.   If interested to join and to receive further details, please send your name and contact information to FACL.Ontario@gmail.com.

The author would be interested to receive any feedback and may be reached at santoslaw@yahoo.com

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Changes to the New Caregiver Program – True Reforms or More of the Same?

NB:  This article was submitted for publication before IRCC announced the reduced work experience requirement (from one year to six months) for HCCP and HSW applications that are already in process.  To date, IRCC has not officially started accepting new applications, or released the implementing guidelines, for the new caregiver program which will grant permanent residency at the outset.     Changes to the New Caregiver Program –  True Reforms or More of the Same? CILA(https://cila.co/author/root-2-2-2/) July 2, 2024(https://cila.co/2024/07/02/) Authored by Maria Deanna P. Santos, Immigration Lawyer at Santos Law Office. On 3 June 2024, the IRCC Minister Marc Miller announced changes to the previous Caregiver Pilot Programs which include the following: Caregivers will be granted permanent residence at the outset IRCC is working towards making the caregiver pilot program permanent The language requirement will be lowered to CLB 4 (from the previous CLB 5) T...

The Misrepresentation Trap

Filipiniana News –   November 2019 by Maria Deanna P. Santos Some people are surprised to learn that even a seemingly 'innocent' act of misrepresentation in the immigration context can lead to a five-year bar from reapplying to enter or remain in Canada.  In Canadian immigration law, misrepresentation is defined as “directly or indirectly misrepresenting or withholding material facts relating to a relevant matter that induces or could induce an error in the administration of the Act.”   The "Act", for those who may not be aware, refers to the main source of Canada's immigration law and policy, the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (IRPA). The words, “directly or indirectly,” in the above definition imply that misrepresentation may be committed by the applicant, permanent resident or by other people.   Direct misrepresentation is quite self-explanatory in that it commonly refers to a deliberate act of lying in one's immigration application...

Parental Sponsorship on Hold; 'Amnesty' for Construction Workers

Filipiniana News –   January 2020 by Maria Deanna P. Santos For the start of 2020, Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC) released the following updates on a couple of its immigration programs which had been much awaited by many and which could potentially have a significant impact on the lives of migrants in Canada.    IRCC Postpones Reopening of Parent-Grandparent Sponsorship Program Many prospective sponsors of parents and grandparents were very disappointed to learn that IRCC has put on hold the parent-grandparent sponsorship program for 2020 until the new ministerial instructions had been released.   No specific date had been provided for their release. In the past years, IRCC had been launching the online interest to sponsor forms at the start of each year to allow prospective sponsors to initiate the sponsorship application process.   Due to various issues which arose from the previous attempts to revise the parental spons...